A small waterfront condominium community beside calm water on Whidbey Island in soft late-autumn light.

Oak Harbor's Median Price Went Up. Here's Why That's Not Good News.

  • November 5, 2026

How does a market's median price rise by 10 percent in the same month its sales nearly halve?

In September 2026, that happened on North Whidbey. According to the Northwest Multiple Listing Service's September Island County breakout, the North Whidbey map area had a median sale price of $569,750 for houses and condos combined, up 10.63 percent from $515,000 a year earlier. NWMLS labels that area 813, "North Whidbey Island," in its map-area index. Oak Harbor is on that part of the island. Closed sales in the same area fell to 32 from 57. Active listings rose to 166 from 135, and months of inventory reached 5.19.

A median price reflects whichever homes happened to sell that month. When the cheaper part of the market stops closing, the median goes up even if no home gained value. That is what the North Whidbey numbers show for September, and it changes how a buyer comparing Oak Harbor with the rest of the region should read that headline figure.

North Whidbey went up while every other part of Island County went down

The September breakout splits Island County into four NWMLS areas. In three of them, the combined house-and-condo median fell from September 2025:

NWMLS area, Sept 2026 Median sale price Change from Sept 2025 Closed sales, 2026 vs 2025
780, Camano Island $667,500 down 10.10% 30 vs 32
811, South Whidbey Island $749,000 down 6.38% 29 vs 37
812, Central Whidbey Island $621,500 down 15.73% 18 vs 12
813, North Whidbey Island $569,750 up 10.63% 32 vs 57
All Island County $618,000 down 3.81% 109 vs 138

North Whidbey is the most affordable of the four areas and the only one with a higher median. It also had the steepest drop in closings, down 43.86 percent. Homes also sold more slowly. Average time on market for North Whidbey closings rose to 57 days from 39, while the county average barely changed, at 58 days versus 56.

Higher prices usually come with more buyers and faster sales. North Whidbey had fewer buyers and slower sales, so the higher median came from a change in which homes sold.

The sales that disappeared were the cheaper ones

The detailed NWMLS Island County area report for September 2026 breaks closings out by property type, and the condo line explains most of the jump. North Whidbey closed 2 condo sales in September 2026, compared with 9 in September 2025. The median price of those condos was $253,000, against $345,000 a year earlier.

Condos sit at the bottom of the price range. When seven fewer of them close in a month with only a few dozen sales, the middle of the remaining list shifts toward pricier single-family homes. That shift alone can lift the median.

The year-to-date figures show the same pattern over more sales, so they are less likely to be noise. Through September 2026, North Whidbey had 32 condo closings, down from 50 over the same months of 2025. House closings fell to 332 from 385, while the year-to-date house median rose to $559,500 from $540,000. Fewer sales and a higher median both come from the same thinning at the bottom.

This pattern is not limited to Oak Harbor. NWMLS's October 6, 2026 market release reported that condos slowed the most across its whole service area in September. Condo pending sales fell 22.7 percent and closed sales fell 19.1 percent, compared with declines of 13.9 and 7.3 percent for single-family homes. Condos had 6.29 months of inventory, against 4.20 for houses. North Whidbey has a larger share of lower-priced homes than the rest of Island County, so that slowdown changes its median more.

The homes for sale at the end of September were priced lower than a year earlier

The closed-sales median looks back at deals that are finished. The active listings show what buyers could choose from as the month ended, and they tell a different story.

At the end of September 2026, the median list price of active North Whidbey house listings was $577,500, down from $644,950 at the end of September 2025. There were 148 active house listings, up from 119, and their average time on market was 92 days, compared with 68 a year earlier.

North Whidbey's sold median went up about 9 percent for houses, while the median asking price of houses for sale went down about 10 percent. Those figures come from the same area in the same month. The homes that closed and the homes waiting for buyers come from different parts of the market. More lower-priced inventory is listed and waiting, and it is staying on the market longer.

For a buyer, the active-listing number is the more useful one. As of September 30, it described the homes that were actually available to tour.

The pending sales point to what closes next

Pending sales come between listings and closings. They are the homes that went under contract and will mostly close in the following month or two.

In September 2026, North Whidbey had 45 house-and-condo pending sales, close to the 49 a year earlier. Their median list price was $500,000, compared with $515,000 in September 2025. Seven of those were condos, with a median list price of $279,900.

The pending figures use list prices, and the closed figures use sale prices, so the two do not compare exactly. Still, a contract pipeline with a $500,000 median list price is well below September's $569,750 closed median. As those contracts close, the cheaper part of the market will show up in the sold numbers again.

Houses alone tell a slightly different story. The median list price of North Whidbey house pendings was $549,250, up from $530,000, on 38 contracts versus 41. Single-family contracts held up better than condos, which matches the regional pattern.

Why prices hold at first and inventory builds

Thin sales at the bottom and stable asking prices at the top have a likely cause in financing costs. The NWMLS release reported that the average 30-year fixed rate rose from 6.71 percent on September 3 to 7.03 percent on September 24, then to 7.28 percent in the first week of October, citing Freddie Mac. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the average at 7.24 percent as of October 29, 2026. A year earlier, on October 30, 2025, it was 6.17 percent.

A rate increase of about one percentage point affects buyers at every price. It does the most damage at the bottom of the market, where buyers are working with the tightest budgets. Steven Bourassa, director of the Washington Center for Real Estate Research, described the result for sellers in the NWMLS release:

"Prices tend to rise quickly in a strong market but can be slower to fall when conditions weaken, in part because sellers may have the flexibility to wait rather than accept a lower price."

When sellers wait, sales slow and listings pile up. In the same release, NWMLS reported that buyers across its service area went under contract on about 62 homes for every 100 new listings in September, down from about 80 a year earlier. It also said service-area inventory was at its highest level since September 2014. North Whidbey's 22.96 percent increase in active listings and 5.19 months of inventory are the local version of that regional trend.

What this means if Oak Harbor is on your list

If you are comparing North Whidbey with Camano, South Whidbey or Skagit County, the September median makes Oak Harbor look like the one market gaining value. The rest of the report gives a different picture of where a buyer stands this fall:

  1. More homes to choose from. North Whidbey had 166 active house-and-condo listings at the end of September, compared with 135 a year earlier.
  2. Listings priced lower. The median list price of active house listings fell to $577,500 from $644,950.
  3. More time to decide. Those active listings averaged 92 days on the market, up from 68.
  4. Condos are the weakest part of the market. North Whidbey condo closings through September fell to 32 from 50.

For sellers, the same numbers mean a higher area median is not a reason to raise an asking price. The homes competing with yours are the active listings, and at the end of September their median list price was lower than it had been a year earlier. Comparable sales from the right price range and property type are a better guide. Our home valuation page is a place to start, and our sellers page explains how we prepare a home for a slower market.

A few quick questions

Is September's 10 percent rise a sign Oak Harbor values are climbing? Not by itself. North Whidbey closed 32 sales in September 2026, and seven fewer condo closings than a year earlier were enough to move the median. The year-to-date house median rose more modestly, to $559,500 from $540,000, while closings fell.

Is new construction part of the picture? A small part. North Whidbey had 21 new-construction house closings through September 2026, down from 31, at a year-to-date median of $659,950. That segment is higher priced than the area overall and shrank this year too.

Which number gives the clearest picture? For buyers, the median list price of active listings and their average time on market. For sellers, recent sales of homes like theirs, matched by property type and price range, rather than one area-wide median.

On North Whidbey, the price of a home now depends more on which part of the market it sits in than on what the median did in a given month. If you are planning a purchase or sale around Oak Harbor, including a move tied to NAS Whidbey Island, The Groesbeck Group can walk you through the condos, starter homes and single-family listings that match your plans, using current numbers for that slice of the market. Our Compass Military page explains how we coordinate moves on tight timelines. Work With Taby.

Work With Taby

Taby manages everything from listings to contracts and closings, marketing, and customer service. Her education, experience, and “make it happen” attitude has been appreciated by our clients and the team.

Follow Us on Instagram